ANALYSIS - Facebook
efforts hint at growing ad clout
Sat May 1, 2010 6:40am IST, By Alexei Oreskovic
Facebook's move to export its social networking
features across the Internet could bolster the company's
advertising business and pose an increasing threat to the
Web's reigning advertising giants.
Facebook, which has more than 400 million registered
users, is the No. 1 website in the United States by page
views, according to comScore. But it is a relatively small
player in the online ad market, where Google Inc's paid
search business dominates, and a variety of Web portals and
ad networks battle over billions of dollars in graphical
display advertising.
With its new initiative to expand beyond the borders of
Facebook.com, however, Facebook has created the framework
for a new generation of highly targeted
ads.
The so-called Open Graph project weaves Facebook's
popular social networking capabilities directly into
third-party websites. A visitor to CNN.com, for instance,
can click a button to "like" certain news articles, and see
which of their Facebook friends have endorsed content on
other websites.
"Having all this data and all this time from consumers
almost can't help but to position Facebook in a very strong
way for online advertisers," said Gartner analyst Augie
Ray.
In the first week, 50,000 websites signed up to provide
Facebook features on their sites, according to the company.
The "like" button was served up to Web surfers visiting
third-party sites more than 1 billion times in the first 24
hours.
All that social activity vastly expands Facebook's trove
of data about users -- information that can improve
marketers' ability to reach consumers that share specific
interests or traits.
"The field in which they (Facebook) can now play, it
went from a 10-yard field to a full football field," said
Michael Lazerow, the CEO of Buddy Media, a firm that helps
companies advertise on Facebook
Jeremiah Owyang, an analyst at Altimeter Group, believes
Facebook will not only collect more data, but expand its
inventory of ad space by eventually serving ads to the
websites offering Facebook's social networking
features.
"This is definitely the precursor to a larger
advertising opportunity," said Owyang, though he said it
will take some time for Facebook to roll out the full
panoply of ad features.
PRIVACY HURDLES
Facebook, which was started by Co-founder and CEO Mark
Zuckerberg in a Harvard dorm room in 2004, makes money
primarily by selling ads on the Facebook.com site. Its
investors include Accel Partners, Microsoft Corp and Hong
Kong tycoon Li Ka-shing.
As a private company, Facebook does not disclose its
financials, though industry estimates for its 2009 revenue
range from $500 million to $650 million -- still just a
fraction of the nearly $24 billion at Google or the $6.5
billion at Yahoo Inc.
Facebook has sharpened its ad focus and hired some of
the people who had a hand in developing Google's
advertising network, including David Fischer, who joined
Facebook as vice president of advertising and global
operations this month.
"The more time that people spend away from Yahoo and
Google, the more that ad dollars will flow away from Yahoo
or Google," said Citigroup analyst Mark Mahaney, though he
noted that Google's paid search business remains the most
effective advertising tool on the Internet.
But before Facebook can transform its advertising
business, it may need to quell growing privacy concerns.
Four U.S. senators this week took issue with Facebook's
automatic integration of user preferences with a trio of
websites.
Privacy concerns have doomed previous attempts by the
company to develop new forms of advertising, notably its
2007 Beacon project that published a person's online
purchases to their Facebook news feed.
"Facebook has had these grandiose visions before and not
all of them come to fruition," said RBC Capital Markets
analyst Ross Sandler.
"When you talk about re-purposing or using consumer
data, that kind of draws a red flag," said Sandler.
Facebook and advertisers, he said, will need to tread
cautiously.
Facebook spokesman Larry Yu said the Open Graph efforts
will not bring about any changes for advertisers.
"Facebook's ad policies remain unchanged. 'Likes' and
interests from people's profiles are aggregated and, as
they have always been able to do, advertisers can target
ads on Facebook with this anonymous information," Yu said
in an emailed statement.
Kevin Lee, the CEO of search engine marketing firm
Didit, said social networking sites have historically
proven to be challenging advertising environments, with
consumers engrossed in interacting with their friends.
But with improved ad targeting and the potential for ads
to appear on other websites, Facebook could play a much
greater role in the ad industry, creating the initial
demand for a product that eventually triggers a Web search,
he said.
"I don't think it's going to displace it (search
advertising), but it's going to be a great adjunct," Lee
said about Facebook.